Color-Coded Chart of U.S. Jobs Growth Since the Recession
Two-tier Table 1 accompanying this article ranks employment changes in the U.S. economy, first by major industry sector, then by selected subsectors, over the period stretching from the end of the recession (July 2009) to the present.
The percentage increase in total employment during the past nine and a half years has been +15.2%. In the lower portion of the table, a thick horizontal line has been drawn to separate subsectors with jobs growth greater than +15.2% from those that have underperformed.
All major industry sectors, − i.e., the same as those highlighted in the monthly Employment Situation Report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), − are included in the table. But only a limited number (59) of subsectors are shown. While 59 may seem like a big number, it’s only a fraction of the total number of workplace categories that are available in the jobs market.
Most of the jobs categories that have been left out, however, have relatively unexciting results to report. Their jobs growth has been lackluster or closely aligned with the national gain. (Two examples are ‘household appliance manufacturing,’ where the jobs change has been +6.7%, and ‘natural gas distribution,’ +2.8%.)
Color-coding has been adopted for the industry and subsectors designations. Yellow is for the kind of private sector work that will mainly take place in offices; orange is for manufacturing; gray for institutional; blue is for jobs serving consumers in wholesale, retail, leisure, and amusement pursuits; and green is for resource extraction and nonmanufacturing industrial work.
By Industry Sector (Fastest to Slowest)
|Rank According to % Change:||Jul 09 Jobs (000s)||Feb 19 Jobs (000s)||% Change|
|1||Transportation & Warehousing||4,214.0||5,537.6||31.4%|
|2||Professional & Business Services||16,474.0||21,311.0||29.4%|
|3||Leisure & Hospitality||13,078.0||16,643.0||27.3%|
|5||Health Care & Social Assistance||16,544.2||20,225.9||22.3%|
|7||Durable Goods Mfg.||7,146.0||8,064.0||12.8%|
|11||Nondurable Goods Mfg.||4,522.0||4,770.0||5.5%|
|Rank According to % Change:||Jul 09 Jobs (000s)||Feb 19 Jobs (000s)||% Change|
|1||Warehousing & Storage||639.5||1,185.3||85.3%|
|2||Companies Offering Temporary Help Services||1,762.3||3,054.1||73.3%|
|3||Electronic Shopping & Electronic Auctions||246.0||398.5||62.0%|
|6||Machinery & Equipment Rental||113.5||175.7||54.8%|
|7||Motor Vehicle & Parts Mfg.||652.9||1,006.0||54.1%|
|8||Computer Systems Design Services||1,424.0||2,167.7||52.2%|
|9||Home Health Care Services||1,029.1||1,510.4||46.8%|
|10||Caterers & Mobile Food Services||153.6||212.0||38.0%|
|11||Couriers & Messenger Services||550.3||754.6||37.1%|
|13||Data Processing & Hosting Services||247.9||332.1||34.0%|
|14||Community Care Facilities for the Elderly||718.1||953.0||32.7%|
|15||Performing Arts & Spectator Sports||396.7||520.4||31.2%|
|16||General Merchandise Stores*||1,510.2||1,958.7||29.7%|
|17||Amusement, Gambling, & Recreation||1,374.7||1,777.2||29.3%|
|18||Waste Management & Remediation Services||349.8||450.5||28.8%|
|19||Food Services & Drinking Places||9,431.0||12,126.4||28.6%|
|20||Elementary & Secondary Schools||852.3||1,094.6||28.4%|
|21||Public Relations Agencies||49.1||63.0||28.3%|
|22||Interior Design Services||34.4||44.1||28.2%|
|24||Motor Vehicles & Parts Dealers||1,626.5||2,037.4||25.3%|
|25||Pet & Pet Supplies Stores||100.5||125.2||24.6%|
|26||Telephone Call Centers||424.9||518.1||21.9%|
|27||Motion Picture & Sound Recording||350.2||424.9||21.3%|
|29||Investigation & Security Services||791.4||947.0||19.7%|
|31||Accommodation (Hotels, Motels, etc.)||1,746.9||2,045.7||17.1%|
|33||Gasoline Stations with Convenience Stores||723.4||842.1||16.4%|
|34||Scientific Research & Development Services||615.9||715.7||16.2%|
|35||Colleges & Universities||1,570.9||1,823.6||16.1%|
|36||Architectural & Engineering Services||1,303.3||1,504.5||15.4%|
|37||Child Day Care Services||846.1||976.7||15.4%|
|38||Transit & Ground Passenger Transportation||422.2||486.8||15.3%|
|39||Travel Arrangement & Reservation Services||189.1||216.6||14.5%|
|40||Environmental Consulting Services||74.6||85.4||14.5%|
|42||Accounting & Bookkeeping Services||913.6||1,036.5||13.5%|
|45||Building Material & Supplies Dealers||1,021.5||1,137.4||11.3%|
|46||Aerospace Products & Parts Mnfg||487.8||528.4||8.3%|
|47||Cement & Concrete Products Mfg.||182.8||195.6||7.0%|
|48||Pharmaceuticals & Medicines Mfg.||283.4||300.2||5.9%|
|50||Semiconductors & Components Mfg.||370.1||376.0||1.6%|
|52||Computer & Peripheral Equipment Mfg.||163.1||161.1||-1.2%|
|53||Oil & Gas Extraction||159.6||150.6||-5.6%|
|58||Book Stores & News Dealers||125.8||75.7||-39.8%|
|59||Video Tape & Disc Rental||85.2||9.1||-89.3%|
|Private Office-Related||Manufacturing||Institutional||Wholesale, Retail, Leisure. & Amusement||Resources & Nonmanufacturing Industrial|
In many instances, the color coding is a judgement call and overlapping is unavoidable – e.g., jobs with ‘couriers and messengers services’ could just as reasonably be categorized to ‘wholesale/retail’ or ‘private office-related’ as to ‘nonmanufacturing industrial’.
Nevertheless, it’s important to take the material and establish order as there are implications for the kinds of construction that will be required based on where the hottest jobs growth is happening. Pickups in ‘professional and business services’ jobs will mean a need for office space. Gains in ‘institutional’ work require educational, medical, and transit capital spending.
Private Office-Related Employment (yellow shading):
The dominant color in the table is yellow, representing ‘private office-related’ employment.
There have been many office-related type-of-job categories where the June 2009 to February 2019 percentage increases in employment have been outsized. Especially striking has been the hike in staffing undertaken by ‘companies offering temporary help services,’ +73.3%. This reflects a sea change in the labor market. Employers have become more willing than in the past to fill job openings with part-time personnel.
Other subsector leaders in private office-related jobs creation have come from the burgeoning high tech sector: ‘software publishing,’ +61.7%; ‘computer systems design services,’ +52.2%; and ‘data processing and hosting services,’ +34.0%.
Strong jobs advances requiring larger office footprints (or more working-from-home, it has to be admitted) have also occurred with: ‘public relations agencies,’ +28.3%; ‘interior design firms,’ +28.2%; ‘telemarketing bureaus,’ +25.6%; ‘telephone call centers,’ +21.9%; and ‘investigation and security services companies,’ +19.7%.
The prevalence of old style storefront travel agencies has been drastically reduced, but in shifting sales venues to the internet, the ‘travel arrangement and reservation services’ subsector has achieved a respectable +14.5% gain in employment over nearly ten years.
Severely underperforming in private office-related employment have been ‘legal services,’ only +1.9%, and ‘commercial banking,’ stalled at +0.1%.
Manufacturing Jobs (orange shading):
During the past nine and a half years, hiring by durable goods manufacturers, at +12.8%, has outpaced personnel additions by nondurables manufacturers, +5.5%.
Many manufacturing subsectors have registered employment gains below the +15.2% for all jobs in the economy. Several have even experienced declines. Showing weakness, on a percentage-change basis, have been: ‘semiconductors and components manufacturing,’ +1.6%; ‘computer and peripheral equipment manufacturing,’ -1.2%; and ‘apparel manufacturing,’ -35.8%. All three of those subsectors have seen diminished activity levels due to competition from emerging nations.
On the upside, there have been two manufacturing subsectors with sizable percentage increases in employment, ‘motor vehicles and parts,’ +54.1%, and ‘beverages,’ +56.8%.
Institutional Jobs (gray shading):
Total government employment since the end of the recession has stayed flat (-0.2%), limiting the scope for public-sector office space construction. Within ‘institutional’ work, however, there have been notable climbs in employment in the health care subsector, arising from a population profile that is aging. (Baby boomers, born between the mid-1940s and mid-1960s, are increasingly entering their ‘golden years.’)
Since July 2009, the number of jobs in ‘home health care services’ has risen +46.8%. And in ‘community care facilities for the elderly,’ staffing has climbed by +32.7%. Only hospitals have disappointed with their lukewarm employment increase of +11.7%.
In the field of education, the hiring increase by ‘elementary and secondary schools,’ at +28.4%, has been almost twice as strong as by ‘colleges and universities,’ +16.1%. It’s interesting to note, though, that the number of jobs in America at the level of higher education (i.e., 1.8 million with ‘colleges and universities’ in February 2019) is greater than at the lower grades (i.e., 1.1 million with ‘elementary and secondary schools’).
Wholesale, Retail, Leisure, and Amusement Jobs (blue shading):
Driven by the systemic shift in retail away from ‘bricks and mortar’ locations to web-based platforms, there has been an accompanying surge in the establishment of facilities to fulfill orders. The consequence, since the recession, has been a +85.3% increase in employment in the ‘warehousing and storage’ segment of the economy, the heftiest jobs increase among all subsectors.
Speaking of web-based selling, the increase in jobs generated by ‘electronic shopping and electronic auctions’ has been a stunningly positive +62.0%.
Some other ‘wholesale and retail’ subsectors with commendable jobs increases since July 2009 have been: ‘caterers and mobile food services,’ +38.0%; ‘general merchandise stores, including warehouse clubs and supercenters,’ +29.7%; ‘motor vehicle and parts dealers,’ +25.3%; and ‘pet and pet supplies stores,’ +24.6%.
In ‘leisure and amusement,’ the jobs winners have been: ‘performing arts and spectator sports,’ +31.2%; ‘amusement, gambling, and recreation,’ +29.3%; and ‘food services and drinking places,’ +28.6%.
There has been a boom in hotel and motel construction over the last several years, but employment in the ‘accommodation’ subsector has been a relatively tame +17.1% since July 2009.
Resources and Nonmanufacturing Industrial Jobs (green shading):
There’s a solid block of green shaded subsectors, for ‘resource and nonmanufacturing work,’ at the bottom of Table 1. ‘Oil and gas extraction’ (-5.6%), ‘logging’ (-7.1%), ‘telecommunications’ (-24.0%), and ‘coal mining’ (-33.9%) have all experienced job losses since July 2009.
On a brighter note, there have been some significant ‘nonmanufacturing industrial’ subsector jobs gains in the fields of: ‘machinery and equipment rental,’ +54.8%; ‘couriers and messenger services,’ +37.1%; and ‘waste management and remediation services&rsquo,; +28.8%.
‘Truck transportation’ employment, at +20.8%, has beaten (but not by a huge margin) the nationwide all-jobs increase, from the end of the recession to the present, of +15.2%.
Nominal Jobs Growth:
As for nominal jobs growth between July 2009 and the latest month for which data is available, February 2019, the frontrunner among major industrial sectors has been ‘professional and business services’ (+4.8 million). Next in line have been: ‘health care and social assistance’ (+3.7 million); ‘leisure and hospitality’ (+3.6 million); ‘construction’ (+1.5 million); and ‘retail trade’ and ‘transportation and warehousing’ (each +1.3 million).
The nominal payroll increase for manufacturers has been +1.17 million jobs, with durables producers contributing +920,000 and nondurables firms, +250,000.
Two sectors have cut staffing. On the downside, ‘utilities’ have trimmed their employee count to a minor degree, -3,000 jobs, but ‘government’ has been more aggressive, -38,000 jobs.
Federal, state, and local government combined, however, continues to be the largest source of jobs in the economy. With a 15.6% share, it ranks ahead of second-place ‘professional and business services’ (14.8%) and third-place ‘health care and social assistance’ (14.0%)
The top 12 subsectors for nominal jobs increases since July 2009 have been: ‘food services and drinking places’ (+2.7 million); ‘companies offering temporary help services’ (+1.3 million); ‘computer systems design services’ (+744,000); ‘warehousing and storage’ (+546,000); ‘hospitals’ (+545,000); ‘home health care services’ (+481,000); ‘general merchandise stores’ (+449,000); ‘motor vehicle and parts dealers’ (+411,000); ‘amusement, gambling, and recreation’ (+403,000); ‘motor vehicle and parts manufacturing’ (+353,000); ‘insurance carriers’ (+342,000); and ‘accommodation’ (+299,000).
As a point of interest, there are currently twice as many people working with ‘motor vehicle and parts dealers’ in retail (2.0 million) as with ‘motor vehicle and parts manufacturers’ (1.0 million).
Also, there are nearly double the number of individuals engaged in food and beverage manufacturing (1.9 million) than in motor vehicle and parts manufacturing (1.0 million).