Further Dips in Unemployment Rates Recorded in U.S. and Canadian September Jobs Reports

In both the U.S. and Canada in September, there was shrinkage in the unemployment rate.

Further Dips in Unemployment Rates Recorded in U.S. and Canadian September Jobs Reports Graphic

The U.S. jobless figure fell to 3.7% from 3.9% in August, according to the latest Employment Situation report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). 3.7% is the lowest level for the U.S. out-of-work rate this century.

Canada’s unemployment rate in September dipped to 5.9% from 6.0% the month prior. While 5.9% is quite tight for north of the border, it has been beaten on a number of occasions over the past decade or so, although not by much. Since the recession, the monthly Canadian unemployment rate has fallen to 5.8% on six occasions, most recently in July of this year.

The total number of U.S. jobs in September rose by +134,000. Since that’s the weakest month-to-month gain in a year, some analysts will conclude that steam is venting from the super-heated jobs market. But there’s a well-hidden number to keep in mind.

The +134,000-jobs figure for September is on top of a revised August number. In the latest BLS report, August was revised upwards by +87,000 jobs. Therefore, September’s total jobs count of 149.5 million compared with August as reported a month ago, at 149.279 million, has not been an increase of just +134,000, but rather of +221,000.

The bottom line is that the extraordinary strength in the American jobs market remains in full force.

The U.S. month-to-month change in total employment this year has averaged +208,000 jobs. The comparable figure for the first nine months of last year was +170,000. This year’s monthly average is ahead by nearly one-quarter (+22.9%) compared with January-September 2017.

Canada’s increase in total employment in September, according to Statistics Canada’s Labour Force Survey, was a healthy +63,000 jobs.

It’s disconcerting, however, that the Canadian numbers have been bouncing around so much. In the past three months, the Canadian jobs total was +54,000 in July; -51,000 in August; and now +63,000 in September.

The volatility has been even more extreme in the monthly figures dealing with part-time work: +82,000 jobs in July; -92,000 in August; and +80,000 in September.

Analysts, of late, have been expressing some doubts about the accuracy of Statcan’s jobs measurements.

On a year-over-year percentage-change basis, the U.S. jobs performance numbers in September were: +1.7% for ‘total’; +1.7% for ‘services’; +2.2% for manufacturing; and +4.5% for construction.

The comparable statistics for Canada have been: +1.2% for total; +1.2% for services; -1.4% for manufacturing; and +2.4% for construction.

U.S. construction employment in September was +23,000 jobs. The average monthly climb in U.S. construction jobs so far this year has been +24,000, or +44% compared with 2017’s first nine-months’ average of +17,000.

Canada’s construction employment in September shot up by +28,000 jobs, but the monthly average for this year has been ‘no change’. In five of the nine months of 2018 so far, there have been cutbacks in Canadian construction employment.

In U.S. industrial sectors other than construction, September’s largest month-to-month staffing improvements occurred in ‘professional and business services’, +54,000; ‘health care and social assistance’, +30,000; and ‘transportation and warehousing’, +24,000.

Government payrolls expanded by +13,000, with the states on a hiring roll (+22,000), while local government retrenched (-8,000) and Washington stood pat (-1,000).

There’s been one remarkable development in U.S. public sector jobs. It was mentioned earlier that August’s total jobs number was revised higher by +87,000. Most of that revision (+66,000) came in the number of jobs credited to government.

As for U.S. sectors where jobs prospects dimmed, ‘retail’ (-20,000) had the worst record in September, followed by ‘leisure and hospitality’ (-17,000).

Compensation stayed in check in the latest month. For all jobs in the U.S. economy, average hourly earnings were +2.8% year over year and average weekly earnings, +3.4%. The comparable percentage changes for construction workers (i.e., as a subset) were +3.1% both hourly and weekly.

Leaving out supervisory personnel, the all-jobs increases were +2.7% hourly and +3.1% weekly. Construction workers fared a bit better at +2.8% hourly and +3.6% weekly.

The latest Canadian figures on average hourly and average weekly earnings for all employees are +2.4% and +2.2% respectively.

As for the average weekly wages of full-time versus part-time workers in Canada, the latter are being rewarded a little more richly than the former, +2.6% year over year versus +2.0% respectively.

Regionally in Canada in September, British Columbia continued to be the front-runner among the provinces for its favorable unemployment rate, only 4.2%. The next best provinces were: Quebec (5.3%); Manitoba (5.8%); and Ontario (5.9%).

Recent voting has installed a new provincial government in Quebec. During the election campaign, the incoming Coalition Avenir Quebec (CAQ) promised increased efforts to attract more investment dollars to ‘la belle province’.

Ontario (+36,000) and B.C. (+33,000) accounted for all the nation’s jobs rise in the latest month. While B.C.’s employment advances were spread among a variety of sectors, Ontario’s were almost entirely in ‘educational services’ (+14,000) and construction (also +14,000).

Other good news on the jobs front concerns Canada joining the U.S. and Mexico in a revamped NAFTA trade agreement, to be known henceforth as USMCA. The ‘partial’ removal of uncertainty (i.e., outstanding tariff issues related to steel and aluminum remain) concerning supply-chain arrangements between the three countries will provide a strong boost to business confidence.

Leave a Reply