Does OSHA Need a Heat Exposure Standard for Construction?
This past July, Public Citizen, a non-profit consumer and health advocacy group, submitted a petition to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) requesting the agency create a new safety standard to protect workers from exposure to excessive heat. In their petition, they claim that many workers, including those in construction, have to work in extreme heat with no protection from heat stress or heat-related illnesses.
From 1992 through 2016, there were 69,374 serious injuries and 783 deaths caused by exposure to excessive heat, per data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Of the 492 occupational fatalities attributed to exposure to environmental heat from 2003 to 2016, 179, or 36%, were in the construction industry.
The petition also cited climate changes as a contributing factor for the need to establish a heat exposure safety standard. 2016 and 2017 where the two all-time hottest years on record. The petition also notes that the frequency of days with extreme heat has been increasing over the past several years.
The petition requests that OSHA include the following items in a new safety standard to protect against heat exposure:
- Provide mandatory rest breaks with increased frequency in times of extreme heat and significant exertion.
- Provide access to shaded and otherwise cool conditions for employees to rest during breaks.
- Provide personal protective equipment, such as water-cooled and air-cooled garments.
- Make provisions for adequate hydration.
- Implement heat acclimatization plans to help new workers safely adjust to hot conditions.
- Regularly monitor both the environmental heat load and employees’ metabolic heat loads
- during hot conditions.
- Medically monitor at-risk employees.
- Notify employees of heat stress hazards.
- Institute a heat-alert plan outlining procedures to follow when heat waves are forecast.
- Train workers on heat stress risks and preventive measures.
- Maintain and report records relating to this standard.
- Institute whistleblower protection programs to ensure that employees who witness violations of the heat stress safety standard are free to speak up.
Establishing a New Heat Exposure Standard
To set a new standard, OSHA can initiate the process on their own or in response to a petition filed by the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS), the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), or any other interested person or parties. If OSHA chooses to establish a new standard, a lengthy process begins that can take months or even years before a final rule is published.
This isn’t the first time that an organization or agency has recommended or petitioned OSHA to initiate the rulemaking process to establish a heat exposure standard. Public Citizen petitioned OSHA to create a heat exposure standard back in 2011 and the NIOSH has recommended OSHA create a specific standard for preventing heat stress three times: in 1972, 1986, and most recently in 2016.
Public Citizen’s petition was denied in 2011. As part of the reasoning behind the decision, OSHA explained that they did not find that exposure to extreme heat created a grave danger to employees, nor did it pose a high enough degree of risk to warrant establishing a permanent standard.
One of the supporters of the current petition is Dr. David Michaels. Dr. Michaels was the director of OSHA when the agency denied Public Citizen’s initial petition. He claims that the health standards staff were already working on rulemaking for other standards at the time and didn’t have the manpower available to take on creating a standard for heat exposure.
Dangers of Exposure to Environmental Heat
Construction workers exposed to extreme heat can suffer a number of heat-related illnesses including heat rash, heat cramps, heat exhaustion, and heat stroke. Workers suffering from heat stroke who don’t receive immediate medical attention can die.
Symptoms of heat exhaustion include headaches; dizziness; weakness; cold, pale or clammy skin; fast or weak pulse; nausea or vomiting and fainting. Not all these symptoms will necessarily be present if suffering from heat exhaustion.
Symptoms of heat stroke include high body temperature (above 103°F); hot, red, dry or moist skin; difficulty breathing; confusion; seizure; heavy sweating; rapid and strong pulse and possible unconsciousness. Heat stroke is the most serious of the two main types of heat illness. Heat stroke can cause major damage to the brain, heart, liver, kidneys and muscles.
Current Protections for Workers
Even without a specific OSHA standard, employers should be doing everything they can to protect construction workers from heat-related illnesses. OSH Act’s General Duty Clause, Section 5(a)(1), states that “Each employer shall furnish to each of his employees employment and a place of employment which are free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm to his employees.”
OSHA has also gone on record, in response to various inquiries for clarification to established rules, that their safety standards are the bare minimum of what employers should be doing to protect their workers. Other safety standards for construction that are relevant to protecting workers from extreme heat exposure include:
29 CFR 1926.21 – Requires employers to train construction workers on how to recognize and avoid unsafe conditions like exposure to extreme heat.
29 CFR 1926.28 – Employers must provide and require workers to use applicable personal protective equipment (PPE) to protect again exposure to hazardous conditions.
29 CFR 1926.50 – Employers are responsible for providing first aid and making provisions for prompt medical attention for serious injuries before beginning a project.
29 CFR 1926.51 – Employers must provide potable water at the jobsite or place of employment for workers to drink.
Tips to Protect Construction Workers From Extreme Heat
In addition to following the above-mentioned OSHA standards, employers can do the following things to help their construction workers understand the dangers posed by exposure to excessive heat and how to protect them from suffering heat-related illnesses:
- Establish a heat illness prevention plan.
- Provide training to employees and supervisors including how to recognize signs and symptoms of heat stress and how to administer first aid.
- Provide water and shaded areas for workers to cool off and encourage them to take frequent breaks throughout the day.
- Get workers acclimated to working in extreme heat over the course of several days.
- Keep an eye on the heat index and take appropriate measures to limit exposure and protect workers.
- Monitor workers and administer first aid or seek medical treatment if a worker is showing any signs of heat stress, heat exhaustion, heat stroke, etc.
Based on OSHA’s past refusal to establish a heat exposure standard, it seems unlikely that they will take up the cause this time around. This doesn’t mean that construction companies should ignore the dangers that exposure to extreme heat poses to their workers. In fact, measures to prevent heat-related illnesses should already be part of your company’s safety program and if it isn’t it should be added and enforced immediately.